Mr. X with an intention to kill Y slabs him on his abdomen, Y who is a patient already, dies immediately because the stab on the abdomen accelerates the death. X is changed of murder Discuss

Facts of the Case

Mr. X intentionally stabbed Y on the abdomen with a sharp weapon, with the purpose of causing death. Y, at the time, was already suffering from pre-existing health conditions. The stab injury accelerated Y’s death, and Y died immediately as a result. The prosecution charged X with murder under Section 302 IPC, alleging intentional homicide.

Issues in the Case

1. Whether Mr. X is liable for murder under Section 302 IPC despite Y’s pre-existing condition?
2. Whether the pre-existing illness of Y can absolve X of criminal liability?
3. Whether intention to cause death (mens rea) is established in this case?
4. Whether the doctrine of causation applies, and X can be held responsible for Y’s death?

Legal Principles Applicable

A. Murder — Section 300 IPC

• Definition: Murder occurs when a person causes death of another with intention or knowledge that the act is likely to cause death.
• Here, X had intention to kill Y, satisfying the mens rea requirement.

B. Causation — Section 300 Explanation (ii) IPC

• Indian law holds that the immediate cause of death need not be the sole cause.
• If X’s act accelerates the death of Y, even if Y was already weak or suffering from illness, X is still liable.
• The principle of “thin skull rule” applies: You take your victim as you find them.

Judicial Precedent:

• In R v Blaue (English law applied in principle) and Indian cases, even pre-existing conditions do not exonerate a person if the act caused death.

C. Section 302 IPC — Punishment for Murder

• Punishable by death or life imprisonment, and fine.
• The intention to kill is sufficient; the actual physical condition of the victim does not negate liability.

D. No Defence under General Exceptions

• Accident (Sec 80 IPC): Not applicable, act was intentional.
• Unsoundness of Mind (Sec 84 IPC): Not alleged.
• Consent or provocation: No evidence.
• Pre-existing condition of victim: Not a defence under IPC.

Possible Judgement

Finding

Mr. X is liable for murder under Section 302 IPC.

Reasoning

1. X intended to kill Y, fulfilling mens rea.
2. X inflicted a fatal stab on the abdomen, which directly caused death, even if Y’s pre-existing condition accelerated it.
3. The law explicitly states that acceleration of death by one’s act makes the perpetrator criminally responsible.
4. No general exception or defence applies.

Offence Committed

• Murder under Section 302 IPC.

Punishment

• Death penalty or life imprisonment, with a fine, as per Section 302 IPC.
• Courts may consider mitigating factors such as provocation or mental condition, but the basic liability for murder is clear.

About lawgnan

If you want clear, exam-oriented explanations of complex IPC concepts like intention, causation, and murder liability, visit Lawgana.in today. Our platform simplifies legal topics with structured notes, case law summaries, and practical illustrations that help law students, judiciary aspirants, and professionals learn faster. Whether you’re preparing for university exams or competitive law tests, Lawgana.in provides reliable, concise, and high-quality content tailored for easy understanding. Explore more criminal law analyses, important sections, and interactive learning tools that strengthen your legal foundation. Start your smarter learning journey now at Lawgana.in.