Understanding the Concept of Bailment
In the course of daily life and commerce, situations often arise where one person hands over goods to another for a specific purpose — such as repair, storage, or transportation — with the understanding that the goods will be returned or dealt with as instructed. This legal relationship is called “Bailment.”
According to Section 148 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872,
“A bailment is the delivery of goods by one person to another for some purpose, upon a contract that they shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed of according to the directions of the person delivering them.”
The person delivering the goods is called the Bailor, and the person to whom they are delivered is called the Bailee. Bailment is based on trust — the Bailee must take reasonable care of the goods, and the Bailor must disclose all material information related to them.
This essay explains the duties and rights of both the Bailor and Bailee, supported by relevant legal provisions and case laws, followed by a mnemonic for easy memorization.
Duties of the Bailor
The Bailor has specific obligations toward the Bailee, which are primarily aimed at ensuring fairness and protection in the bailment relationship. The main duties are as follows:
1. Duty to Disclose Faults in Goods (Section 150)
The Bailor must disclose to the Bailee any known defects in the goods that might interfere with the use of the goods or expose the Bailee to risk.
If he fails to do so, he is responsible for any resulting loss.
Case Law: Hyman v. Nye & Sons (1881) — The owner of a carriage failed to inform the hirer of defects, leading to an accident. The court held the owner liable.
2. Duty to Bear Extraordinary Expenses (Section 158)
If the bailment is gratuitous (without reward), the Bailor must bear any extraordinary expenses incurred by the Bailee while maintaining the goods.
Example: If A lends his horse to B for riding and the horse falls ill, A must reimburse the medical expenses.
3. Duty to Indemnify the Bailee (Sections 159–164)
- When the Bailor terminates a gratuitous bailment before its due time and the Bailee suffers loss, the Bailor must indemnify him (Sec. 159).
- If the Bailor had no title to the goods and the Bailee suffers loss, the Bailor must indemnify the Bailee (Sec. 164).
Case Law: Kalyani Breweries Ltd. v. State of West Bengal (1975) — The Bailor was held liable to indemnify for losses caused by wrongful possession.
Rights of the Bailor
The Bailor, while transferring possession, does not lose ownership and hence retains certain rights:
1. Right to Demand Return of Goods
After the purpose of bailment is accomplished, the Bailor has the right to claim the return of the goods in the same or improved condition.
2. Right to Compensation for Unauthorized Use (Section 154)
If the Bailee uses the goods for a purpose other than the one agreed upon, the Bailor can claim compensation or terminate the bailment.
Case Law: Coggs v. Bernard (1703) — The Bailee used goods contrary to instructions and was held liable for damages.
3. Right to Terminate Bailment
The Bailor can terminate the bailment if the Bailee acts inconsistently with its terms (Sec. 153).
4. Right to Recover Compensation for Negligence
If the Bailee fails to take reasonable care and the goods are damaged, the Bailor can recover compensation for the loss.
Thus, the Bailor enjoys the right to ensure that his property is protected and properly used during the bailment period.
Duties of the Bailee
The Bailee, being the custodian of another’s property, has a fiduciary responsibility to handle the goods with due care and in accordance with the contract.
1. Duty to Take Reasonable Care (Section 151)
The Bailee must take as much care of the goods as a person of ordinary prudence would take of his own goods.
Case Law: Chalmers v. Royal Mail Steam Co. (1905) — The Bailee was held liable for loss due to negligence.
2. Duty Not to Make Unauthorized Use (Section 154)
The Bailee must use the goods only for the agreed purpose. Unauthorized use makes him liable for damages, even if the goods are not harmed.
3. Duty Not to Mix Bailor’s Goods (Sections 155–157)
The Bailee must not mix the Bailor’s goods with his own without consent. If mixed:
- With consent: Both share in proportion.
- Without consent and separable: Bailee bears separation cost.
- Without consent and inseparable: Bailee compensates Bailor for loss.
4. Duty to Return Goods (Section 160)
The Bailee must return or deliver the goods once the bailment purpose is complete.
5. Duty to Return Increases or Profits (Section 163)
If any profit arises from the goods (like offspring of animals or interest on securities), it belongs to the Bailor.
Rights of the Bailee
The Bailee’s rights ensure that his efforts, expenses, and liabilities are fairly protected during the bailment.
1. Right to Compensation (Section 164)
If the Bailor had no right to make bailment and the Bailee suffers loss, the Bailee can recover compensation.
2. Right to Reimbursement of Expenses (Section 158)
If the Bailee incurs lawful extraordinary expenses in keeping the goods, he can claim reimbursement from the Bailor.
3. Right of Lien (Sections 170–171)
The Bailee can retain possession of goods until due charges are paid.
- Particular lien (Sec. 170): Retain specific goods for charges related to them.
- General lien (Sec. 171): Available to bankers, factors, attorneys, and policy brokers.
Case Law: Scarf v. Jardine (1882) — Recognized the right of general lien for bankers.
4. Right to Deliver Goods to Bailor (Section 165)
If multiple persons claim ownership, the Bailee can deliver goods to the Bailor without liability for wrongful delivery.
5. Right to Recover Loss or Indemnity
The Bailee can seek indemnity from the Bailor if he suffers any loss due to defective goods or false representation.
Case Laws Illustrating Duties and Rights
- Coggs v. Bernard (1703) – Established Bailee’s liability for unauthorized use.
- Hyman v. Nye & Sons (1881) – Bailor’s duty to disclose defects.
- Kalyani Breweries Ltd. v. State of West Bengal (1975) – Bailor’s liability to indemnify.
- Chalmers v. Royal Mail Steam Co. (1905) – Bailee’s duty of reasonable care.
- Scarf v. Jardine (1882) – Bailee’s right of general lien.
These cases form the backbone of judicial interpretation of bailment law, ensuring accountability on both sides.
Real-Life Example
Consider A, who gives his laptop to B, a repair technician, to fix certain issues.
- Duties of Bailor: A must disclose if the laptop has any pre-existing hardware problems or damaged parts.
- Duties of Bailee: B must handle the laptop carefully and use it only for repair. If he uses it for personal work or damages it, he is liable to compensate A.
- Rights: Once the repair is done, B can retain the laptop until A pays his service charges (right of lien). A, on the other hand, has the right to get back the laptop in the repaired condition.
This simple example shows how the legal principles of bailment operate in everyday transactions.
Mnemonic to Remember – “B.A.I.L.E.D.”
Use the mnemonic “B.A.I.L.E.D.” to remember the key points about Duties and Rights of Bailor and Bailee:
- B – Bailor must disclose defects (Sec. 150)
- A – Authorized use only (Bailee must follow contract)
- I – Indemnity rights for both (Secs. 159–164)
- L – Lien rights of Bailee (Secs. 170–171)
- E – Extraordinary expenses reimbursed (Sec. 158)
- D – Duty of care by Bailee (Sec. 151)
Mnemonic Sentence:
“Bailment Always Involves Legal, Ethical Dealings.”
This phrase helps recall that Bailment is a relationship of trust, governed by mutual duties, rights, and fairness.
About lawgnan:
Deepen your understanding of Bailment under the Indian Contract Act, 1872 — including rights and duties of the Bailor and Bailee — with expert-curated study materials at Lawgnan.in. Learn from detailed explanations, case laws, and practical examples that simplify complex legal concepts for LLB exams and judicial preparation. Lawgnan provides updated law notes, model answers, and previous question papers to help students master contract law topics effortlessly. Visit Lawgnan.in today to access comprehensive resources on Bailment, Contract Law, and other essential subjects for academic success and legal excellence.
