Examine the privileges of legislature under the Constitution of India

Significance of Legislative Privileges in a Democracy

In a democratic system governed by the Constitution of India, the Legislature plays a vital role in law-making, ensuring accountability, and representing the will of the people. To perform these duties effectively and independently, the Constitution confers certain special rights, powers, and immunities known as Legislative Privileges.

These privileges protect the freedom, dignity, and authority of the legislative bodies, enabling members to express their opinions freely without fear of legal consequences or executive interference. The primary aim is to ensure smooth functioning of legislative proceedings, thereby strengthening the principle of separation of powers between the Legislature, Executive, and Judiciary.

Constitutional Basis of Legislative Privileges

The Constitution of India provides for the privileges of Parliament and State Legislatures under Articles 105 and 194.

• Article 105 deals with the Powers, Privileges, and Immunities of Parliament and its members.
• Article 194 extends similar privileges to State Legislatures and their members.

Article 105(1): Freedom of Speech in Parliament

This clause grants members the freedom of speech and expression within the House, subject to the provisions of the Constitution and the rules of the House. Members cannot be held liable in any court for anything said or any vote given in Parliament.

Article 105(2): Immunity from Legal Proceedings

It ensures that no Member of Parliament shall be liable to any proceedings in court for anything said or any vote given in Parliament or its committees.

Article 105(3): Other Privileges

It provides that the other privileges of Parliament shall be the same as those of the House of Commons of the UK Parliament, until defined by law.

Similarly, Article 194(1)–(3) grants equivalent powers and immunities to the State Legislatures and their members.

Thus, legislative privileges form an essential constitutional mechanism that preserves the autonomy and dignity of the legislative institution.

Objectives and Importance of Legislative Privileges

The privileges of the Legislature serve several important functions in a democratic framework:

1. Ensuring Independence: Members can freely discuss, debate, and criticize without external pressure.
2. Maintaining Dignity and Authority: Safeguards the House from contempt or obstruction in its proceedings.
3. Upholding Separation of Powers: Prevents judicial or executive encroachment into legislative functions.
4. Encouraging Free Speech: Members can represent people’s interests without fear of defamation or prosecution.
5. Protecting Parliamentary Democracy: Ensures the effective functioning of the House and its committees.

These privileges are not meant for personal benefit but are essential to protect the institutional integrity of the Legislature.

Types of Legislative Privileges

Legislative privileges are broadly divided into collective and individual privileges.

A. Collective Privileges (of the House as a Whole)

1. Right to Regulate Internal Proceedings: The House has the right to manage its internal affairs without interference from the courts.
2. Power to Punish for Contempt: The House can punish members or outsiders for contempt or breach of privilege.
3. Right to Exclude Strangers: The House can exclude non-members to maintain confidentiality.
4. Publication Control: The House can control the publication of debates and proceedings.
5. Right to Enforce Attendance: It can compel the attendance of members and witnesses before committees.

B. Individual Privileges (of the Members)

1. Freedom of Speech in the House (Article 105(1)): Members can speak freely on any matter under discussion.
2. Freedom from Arrest: Members are immune from arrest in civil cases during the session of the House and 40 days before and after it. (This does not extend to criminal cases.)
3. Freedom from Legal Action: Members cannot be sued or prosecuted for speeches or votes given in the House.
4. Right to Receive Information: Members have the right to ask questions and seek information from the executive.

Breach of Privilege and Contempt of the House

A breach of privilege occurs when any member or outsider interferes with or undermines the authority or functioning of the House or its members. This may include acts such as:

• Publishing defamatory statements about members.
• Misreporting debates or proceedings.
• Disobedience to orders or summons issued by the House.
• Obstruction of legislative work or disobedience of privilege committee orders.

The House has the power to punish for contempt, which may include reprimand, admonition, or imprisonment.

A famous example of such punishment occurred in Searchlight Case (1959), where the editor of a newspaper was punished for publishing remarks expunged from the proceedings of the Bihar Legislative Assembly.

Judicial Interpretation and Landmark Cases

Several judgments have clarified the scope and limitations of legislative privileges under the Constitution.

(i) M.S.M. Sharma v. Sri Krishna Sinha (Searchlight Case, 1959)

The Supreme Court held that legislative privileges under Article 194(3) prevail over the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a). However, such privileges must be exercised within constitutional boundaries.

(ii) Keshav Singh v. Speaker, Legislative Assembly, U.P. (1965)

This case arose when the Legislative Assembly of U.P. ordered the imprisonment of a citizen for contempt. The Supreme Court ruled that although the Legislature has the power to punish for contempt, its privileges are subject to judicial review when there is a constitutional violation.

(iii) Raja Ram Pal v. Hon’ble Speaker, Lok Sabha (2007)

This case reaffirmed that while Parliament is supreme within its own sphere, its privileges are not absolute. The Court held that judicial review is available to ensure that legislative privileges are not exercised arbitrarily or mala fide.

These cases collectively emphasize that legislative privileges and fundamental rights must co-exist harmoniously under the constitutional framework.

Limitations on Legislative Privileges

Although legislative privileges are essential, they are not unlimited.
Some key limitations include:

1. Subject to Fundamental Rights: Privileges cannot override basic constitutional rights, especially those under Part III.
2. Judicial Review: The courts can intervene if privileges are misused or if the actions of the Legislature violate constitutional provisions.
3. Not Codified Yet: The privileges have not been fully defined by law, leading to uncertainty and potential misuse.
4. Moral and Political Responsibility: The Legislature is answerable to the public and must exercise privileges responsibly.

Need for Codification of Privileges

Despite constitutional recognition, India has not yet codified legislative privileges by law. This leads to ambiguity and potential conflict between the Legislature and Judiciary. Codification would:

• Clearly define the scope and nature of privileges.
• Prevent arbitrary exercise of power.
• Strengthen accountability and transparency.
• Maintain the balance between privileges and fundamental rights.

Until then, judicial precedents and parliamentary conventions continue to guide the interpretation and application of legislative privileges.

Mnemonic to Remember — “S.P.E.A.K.”

Use the mnemonic “S.P.E.A.K.” to easily recall the key aspects of Legislative Privileges under the Constitution of India:

• S – Speech Freedom (Art. 105/194) – Freedom of speech within the House.
• P – Protection from Arrest – Immunity from arrest in civil cases during sessions.
• E – Exclusive Control – Legislature regulates internal proceedings.
• A – Authority to Punish – Power to punish for contempt or breach of privilege.
• K – Knowledge Power – Right to seek information and question the executive.

Mnemonic Meaning: “Legislators S.P.E.A.K. freely — Speech, Protection, Exclusive control, Authority, and Knowledge.”

About lawgnan

Explore the Significance of Legislative Privileges in India with an in-depth analysis of Articles 105 and 194 at Lawgnan.in. Learn how these constitutional provisions empower legislators to act freely, maintain independence, and protect democratic integrity. Discover landmark cases like Raja Ram Pal v. Speaker, Searchlight Case, and Keshav Singh v. Speaker, which define the limits and scope of legislative privileges. Perfect for law students, UPSC aspirants, and judiciary exam candidates, this article breaks down privileges, powers, and responsibilities of Parliament and State Legislatures in simple terms. Visit Lawgnan.in to master key constitutional concepts today.