Meaning and Concept of Domestic Enquiry
A Domestic Enquiry is an internal disciplinary procedure conducted by an employer to investigate allegations of misconduct against a workman. Though the term is not expressly defined in the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, its legal basis flows from principles of natural justice and is recognized under labour jurisprudence and the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946. Standing orders framed under Section 2(g) generally prescribe the procedure for conducting a domestic enquiry. The main purpose of a domestic enquiry is to determine whether the charges of misconduct are proved and whether disciplinary action is justified. It ensures fairness, transparency, and due process before imposing penalties such as dismissal or suspension. A properly conducted domestic enquiry protects both the employer and the employee.
Principles and Procedure of Domestic Enquiry
A domestic enquiry must strictly follow the principles of natural justice, namely audi alteram partem (right to be heard) and nemo judex in causa sua (no one should be a judge in his own cause). The workman must be issued a charge sheet clearly stating the allegations and must be given adequate opportunity to defend himself. The enquiry officer must be impartial and unbiased. The workman has the right to cross-examine witnesses and produce evidence in his defense. Though the strict rules of the Evidence Act do not apply, the findings must be based on some evidence. Courts have emphasized fair procedure in cases like Workmen of Firestone Tyre & Rubber Co. v. Management (1973).
Legal Effect and Judicial Review
The findings of a domestic enquiry have significant legal consequences. If the enquiry is conducted fairly and in accordance with natural justice, labour courts generally do not interfere with the employer’s decision. However, under Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, labour courts have the power to reappraise evidence and modify the punishment if it is found to be disproportionate. If the enquiry is found to be defective or unfair, the employer may be required to prove the misconduct afresh before the labour court. Thus, domestic enquiry plays a vital role in maintaining discipline while safeguarding workers’ rights.
Real-Time Practical Example
A factory worker is accused of habitual absenteeism and misconduct. The management issues a charge sheet and appoints an enquiry officer to conduct a domestic enquiry. The worker is allowed to present his explanation, cross-examine witnesses, and submit documents. After examining the evidence, the enquiry officer finds the charges proved and submits a report. Based on the report, the management imposes a penalty in accordance with the standing orders. If the worker challenges the action, the labour court examines whether the enquiry followed principles of natural justice. This shows the practical importance of domestic enquiry in industrial discipline.
Mnemonic to Remember Domestic Enquiry
Mnemonic: “F.A.I.R”
F – Follow natural justice
A – Audi alteram partem
I – Impartial enquiry officer
R – Reasoned findings
This mnemonic helps recall the essential elements of a valid domestic enquiry during examinations.
About lawgnan
Domestic Enquiry is a highly examinable topic in OU LLB Labour Law-I, especially in problem-based questions. For clear explanations, case laws, procedural steps, mnemonics, and exam-ready answers, visit lawgana.in. LawGana offers structured and simplified legal content designed for Indian law students. Whether you are revising Standing Orders or disciplinary procedures, LawGana helps you write precise and confident answers in exams. Follow lawgana.in today and strengthen your labour law preparation with clarity and confidence.
