Definition and Legal Basis
Documentary evidence refers to any written, printed, or electronic record produced for proving a fact in issue or relevant facts in a legal proceeding. Under Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, documentary evidence includes any matter expressed or described in a document. Sections 61 to 90 of the Evidence Act provide detailed rules regarding the admissibility, proof, and conditions for using documentary evidence in both civil and criminal cases. The purpose of documentary evidence is to provide reliable, permanent, and verifiable proof that can supplement or replace oral testimony, ensuring the court has concrete material to examine.
Types of Documentary Evidence
Documentary evidence is generally classified as:
- Public Documents: Official records issued by a public authority, such as birth certificates, government orders, or land records. Sections 74–78 Evidence Act govern their authenticity.
- Private Documents: Records created by private individuals or organizations, such as contracts, letters, or agreements. Sections 61–63 deal with their proof.
- Primary and Secondary Evidence: Primary evidence is the original document itself, while secondary evidence includes certified copies, oral accounts, or counterparts when originals are unavailable. Section 65 outlines conditions for admissibility of secondary evidence.
- Electronic Records: Digital documents, emails, or messages admissible under Sections 65A and 65B, provided the conditions for authenticity and reliability are satisfied.
Evidentiary Value and Conditions
Documentary evidence is considered strong and reliable because it is often permanent and less prone to distortion. For admissibility, the document must satisfy:
- Authenticity: Proven to be genuine and unaltered.
- Relevance: Must relate directly to the facts in issue.
- Compliance with statutory rules: Public or electronic documents must follow Sections 65A, 65B, or 74–78 as applicable.
Courts carefully examine signatures, stamps, dates, and corroboration to ensure the document is credible. The weight of documentary evidence increases when supported by oral or circumstantial evidence, providing a comprehensive proof of facts.
Real-Time Example
In a property dispute, the plaintiff produces the original sale deed as documentary evidence under Sections 61–65 of the Evidence Act. The deed contains details of the transaction, signatures of parties, and the date of registration. Additionally, land records certified by the revenue office serve as public documents corroborating ownership. These documents, supplemented by oral testimony from witnesses who attended the transaction, allow the court to reliably determine the rightful ownership of the property.
Mnemonic to Remember
Mnemonic: “D-O-C-U-M-E-N-T”
- D – Documented Fact: Written, printed, or digital.
- O – Original vs Copy: Primary and secondary evidence.
- C – Certified Public Records: Government-issued documents.
- U – Unaltered and Authentic: Must be genuine.
- M – Must be Relevant: Pertains to facts in issue.
- E – Electronic Records: Admissible under Sections 65A & 65B.
- N – Notarized/Attested: Ensures credibility.
- T – Tested in Court: Can be cross-examined or verified.
About lawgnan
Understand documentary evidence in a clear, structured, and exam-oriented manner on Lawgana.in. Our platform breaks down complex provisions of the Evidence Act, including Sections 61–90, public and private documents, primary and secondary evidence, and electronic records under Sections 65A and 65B. With easy explanations, real-life examples, mnemonics, and case-based insights, Lawgana.in helps law students, judiciary aspirants, and legal researchers master documentary proof with confidence. Visit Lawgana.in today to strengthen your concepts and enhance your preparation with high-quality legal content designed for scoring and clarity.
