Facts of the Case
- B has committed the offence of murder of Z.
- A is fully aware that B has intentionally killed Z, which is a punishable offence under Section 302 IPC.
- After gaining this knowledge, A assists B in hiding the dead body, with the deliberate intention of helping B escape criminal liability.
- A’s conduct takes place after the murder has already been committed, and his intention is not to participate in murder, but to help B avoid detection and punishment.
The question is whether A’s act of assisting B after the commission of murder constitutes an offence under the Indian Penal Code.
Issues in the Case
- Whether A’s act of hiding the body constitutes an offence under IPC?
- Whether A can be treated as an abettor to murder, or only as an accessory after the fact?
- Whether Sections 201, 202, or 212 IPC apply to A’s conduct?
- Whether knowledge of the murder and intention to screen the offender is sufficient to impose criminal liability on A?
Legal Principles Covered
A. Section 201 IPC — Causing Disappearance of Evidence of an Offence
This section applies when:
- A person, knowing or having reason to believe that an offence has been committed,
- Causes disappearance of evidence of that offence,
- Or gives false information,
- With the intention of screening the offender from legal punishment.
In this case:
- A knows B committed murder (a serious offence).
- A actively helps hide the body, which is direct removal of crucial evidence.
- His intention is clearly to help B escape punishment.
Thus, A’s conduct perfectly fits Section 201 IPC.
Penalty under Section 201:
- If the offence is murder, the punishment may extend to 7 years imprisonment and fine.
B. Section 212 IPC — Harbouring Offender
This section applies when:
- A person harbours or conceals an offender,
- Knowing that the offender has committed an offence,
- With the intention of helping him evade punishment.
If A not only hides the body but also provides shelter, resources, or assistance to B, he may additionally fall under Section 212 IPC.
However, in the given facts, the focus is on hiding the corpse, not harbouring B.
Thus, Section 212 may or may not apply depending on further facts.
C. Not an Abettor to Murder (Sections 107–109 IPC)
- Abetment requires instigation, conspiracy, or intentional aiding before or during the commission of the offence.
- A acted after the murder was complete.
- Hence, A is not liable for abetment of murder under Sections 107–109 IPC.
D. Mens Rea Requirement
For liability under Section 201 IPC:
- Knowledge of the offence, and
- Intention to screen the offender
are essential.
Here:
- A knew about the murder, satisfying the knowledge element.
- A hid the body specifically to save B, satisfying the intention element.
Thus, mens rea is clearly established.
E. Section 202 IPC — Intentional Omission to Give Information
This section applies if a person:
- Knowing a crime has been committed,
- Fails to inform authorities.
But A goes beyond mere omission.
He actively destroys evidence.
Therefore, the more serious offence under Section 201 IPC applies.
Possible Judgement
Finding
A is criminally liable under Indian Penal Code.
Reasoning
- A knowingly assisted in destroying the most vital evidence of the offence—the dead body.
- His intention was explicitly to help B avoid legal consequences.
- This constitutes causing disappearance of evidence of murder under Section 201 IPC.
- Under no circumstances can A claim defence of good faith or absence of intent.
Applicable Law
- Section 201 IPC directly applies and is sufficient to establish liability.
- Depending on additional facts, Section 212 IPC could also be applied.
Conclusion / Judgement
A would be convicted under Section 201 IPC for intentionally causing the disappearance of evidence of murder to protect B from punishment.
The punishment may extend to seven years imprisonment along with fine.
A is not liable for murder, but is fully liable as an accessory after the fact for destroying evidence.
About lawgnan
For more clarity on criminal liability under the Indian Penal Code—such as offences involving evidence destruction, harbouring offenders, conspiracy, and abetment—visit Lawgana.in for detailed, structured, and reliable legal explanations. Lawgana.in provides case-based reasoning, easy-to-understand notes, and exam-focused insights designed for law students, judiciary aspirants, and legal professionals. Strengthen your conceptual understanding of IPC sections like 201, 202, 212, and many more through simplified illustrations and analytical breakdowns. Explore hundreds of legal topics and build a strong legal foundation with high-quality content. Visit Lawgana.in today to learn smarter and score higher.
